Best Toasters in 2025

The Cuisinart CPT-435 is a top-rated 4-slice toaster that consistently delivers excellent toasting results. It features dual control panels, allowing independent operation of each pair of slots, making it ideal for households with varied toasting preferences. Its extra-wide slots can accommodate bagels, English muffins, and artisan bread, providing versatility. The seven browning settings, along with bagel and defrost functions, cater to a wide range of toasting needs. The stainless steel construction gives it a premium look and feel. Toasting is extremely even, and the controls are intuitive, although they take a bit of getting used to. We highly recommend the CPT-435 because of its exceptional toasting consistency and feature set.

The Black+Decker TR1400D is an excellent budget-friendly toaster that doesn't compromise on essential features. It's a simple but effective 2-slice toaster with extra-wide slots and a variety of toasting settings, including a bagel function and a defrost option. It’s designed to be easy to use, with clear controls and a convenient cancel button. Built with a stylish design, the TR1400D delivers good value for the price. Although it lacks some of the advanced features and build quality of more expensive models, its performance is more than satisfactory for everyday toasting needs, making the Black+Decker TR1400D a great option for consumers seeking an affordable and functional toaster.

The Breville Smart Toaster Pro offers sophisticated toasting technology, making it a standout choice for those who want precise and consistent results. Its motorized lift automatically lowers and raises bread, while "A Bit More" and "Lift & Look" features allow customized toasting. It provides a remarkable level of control over the toasting process, ensuring toast is perfect every time. The Smart Toaster Pro employs an 'auto-sensing' feature that adjusts toasting time based on the bread type, offering exceptional performance and convenience. Additional features like a 'Fruit Bread' setting help provide optimal results. The high-end build quality ensures improved durability. While its price point is higher, the outstanding toasting quality and advanced features justify the cost for serious toast enthusiasts. Smart toasting really does make a difference.

The Hamilton Beach 22790 is a simple, reliable 2-slice toaster designed for everyday use. It provides basic toasting functions with a focus on ease of use and a good value proposition. Its features include extra-wide slots, a cancel button, and adjustable browning controls, which provide enough options to meet most users' needs. This is not a toaster with bells and whistles, which is part of its appeal. It offers good performance for the price, making this an excellent option for anyone seeking a straightforward and reliable toaster. For consumers prioritizing simplicity, it's a very solid option.

The KitchenAid KMT422 is a stylish and feature-rich toaster, known for its excellent performance and attractive design. It is a four-slice toaster that offers multiple shade settings and a bagel function for customized toasting. The KitchenAid KMT422 also boasts an impressive even-toasting performance, ensuring your bread, bagels, and other items are toasted to perfection. Its simple and intuitive controls make it easy to operate. The stainless-steel construction and overall durability make it a great addition to any kitchen. While the price point is higher, the superior performance, multiple features, and aesthetic appeal make this a smart choice for those who value both style and functionality. The KitchenAid KMT422 can handle large volumes of work.